What if your new trainers didn’t just make you feel enthusiastic, but actually made running easier for you? There is a new breed of shoes on the market which claims to do just that.
The precise measure of how effectively you run is known as your running economy: it is the amount of oxygen you need to breathe in order to maintain a certain velocity, known as VO2. The lower your VO2, the more effectively you are running [1].
Energy return shoes claim to improve running economy by harnessing energy that would otherwise be lost. Every time your foot hits the ground, energy is transferred out through pressure on your shoes.
Energy return styles claim to store some of this energy and give it back to you, in the form of extra bounce to help you push off again for your next step. Over the course of a whole run, it could make you go further and faster.
Some advanced footwear designs improve running economy in controlled studies, but individual responses vary. This does not establish that every energy-return shoe is more comfortable or prevents injury.
Shoe mass, foam, geometry and fit can affect running experience. A change in running economy is not the same as a demonstrated change in injury risk. running economy or your risk of injury
For recreational runners, comfort and injury history matter alongside performance goals. Energy-return shoes are not inherently unsuitable for casual running.
Cushioning and Running Injury Risk
Laboratory impact measurements do not translate directly into injury risk. Surface, speed, training and individual factors all matter.
Trials do not support a blanket claim that heavily cushioned shoes cause more injuries. Results depend on the shoes and runners studied.
More cushioning does not necessarily reduce running economy. Foam properties, shoe mass and geometry interact.
Considering Energy-Return and Minimalist Shoes
Research on the body’s adaptations to impact has led to a recent craze for ‘minimalist’ shoes: with paper-thin soles and flexible uppers, they feel more like rubbery socks than shoes.
Minimalist shoes change loading and may improve economy in some settings. A rapid transition can increase stress on the foot and calf; imaging studies have reported bone stress changes, not a universal rate of painful injury.
Energy return shoes aim to improve running economy with advanced technology that lifts you off the road; minimalist shoes try to bring you as close as possible to running barefoot, allowing your body to move naturally.
Neither advanced cushioning nor minimalist construction is best for everyone. Studies differ in design and outcomes, so avoid treating all shoes in either category as equivalent.
If you’re experiencing heel pain while running, then you’ll want to read our article about our leading podiatrist Tim Maiden’s favourite running shoe selections.
If you’ve been to a large sports shop, you’ve probably been subjected to gait analysis – where someone sticks you on a treadmill and thoughtfully prescribes a shoe to make your run ‘properly’.
Comfort Above All When Selecting The Right Shoes
After decades of conflicting evidence, researchers have proposed that people instinctively know the right shoe for them. We’ve gone full circle, and sports science now harks back to what your mum told you when buying school shoes.
Try shoes for fit and comfort, with enough toe room and secure heel fit. Comfort is useful but does not guarantee that a shoe will prevent injury.
The comfort-filter idea is a proposed approach to shoe selection, not proof that a comfortable shoe necessarily improves economy or prevents injury.
Choose a comfortable shoe suited to the activity and introduce substantial design changes gradually.
A podiatrist can assess your footwear and discuss comfort or persistent foot pain. No shoe or assessment can prevent every injury. Find out more about our footwear assessment services.
Sources
[1] Beverly, J. The Truth About Energy Return in Your Shoes. Runner’s World. October 15, 2015.
[2] Weijie Fu (et. al), Surface effects on in-shoe plantar pressure and tibial impact during running,
Journal of Sport and Health Science, Volume 4, Issue 4, 2015, Pages 384-390, ISSN 2095-2546, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jshs.2015.09.001.
[3] Isabel Sarah Moore, Andrew Jones & Sharon Dixon (2014) The pursuit of improved running performance: Can changes in cushioning and somatosensory feedback influence running economy and injury risk?, Footwear Science,6:1, 1-11, DOI: 10.1080/19424280.2013.873487.
[4] A. W. Johnson (et. al). The Effects of a Transition to Minimalist Shoe Running on Intrinsic Foot Muscle Size. Int J Sports Med 2016; 37(02): 154-158. DOI: 10.1055/s-0035-1559685.